PrOACT-based Decision Activity Example

Problem
What is the best breakfast for me as I get ready for my high school day?

Objectives
By eating breakfast I can:

Alternatives

My realistic choices for breakfast are:

O-A table

Alternatives

 
Objective
No breakfast
Toast/milk
Pop-tart
Cereal
Protein
Nourishment
 
***
**
***
****
Prevent growl
 
**
**
***
****
Satisfy adult
 
***
**
****
*****
Mimic friends
**
****
*****
**
*
Be on time
*****
***
*****
**
 
[If one objective is much more important than others, the choice may be apparent at this point.]

Consequences

Now I must consider what will happen if I make one of these choices. Look at the consequences:

    • If I skip breakfast to be on time, I will get no nourishment but will get a lot of hassle from that adult because I don't take care of myself! I will be embarrassed when my stomach growls in 3rd period, too.

    • If I have a highly nourishing breakfast, I will surely be late for school. The adult will be pleased with my choice of meals but will hassle me when I miss my ride. I could get a detention, but my stomach wouldn't growl.

The other alternatives have consequences too, but not as great, so I should probably choose one of those.

 

Tradeoffs

I will probably have a pop-tart or something like that. It will be quick and it has some nutritional value. I should be able to make it through to lunch, especially if I throw a second one into my backpack. I have traded off real nutrition, but I will try to have a good lunch.

 
 

From Decision Making Activities for the Great Lakes
Developed by the Ohio Sea Grant Education Program, The Ohio State University
© 2003, updated 2010